Martha Marcy May Marlene (2011) Director: Sean Durkin,
Starring; Elizabeth Olsen, John Hawkes, Sarah Paulson
Rating: 4/5
Told in a non-linear narrative that shows most of the
details in flashback, this creepy and effective film explores the life of an
escapee from a David Koresh-style cult. Cold and without clear resolution, it
successfully shows more than it tells, never attempting to pass judgement at
either Martha’s (Elizabeth Olsen) redemption, or time with the cult.
The opening scene establishes Martha’s escape, and she then
calls her sister, whom hasn't heard from her in two years. What follows is a
particularly difficult transition back into the normal life of her sister Lucy
(Sarah Paulson), and her wealthy and focused husband (Hugh Dancy). A clearly
strained relationship already exists between the two sisters, and when Lucy
overreacts to Martha swimming naked in a nearby lake, her reaction is one which
questions her ability to become a mother. Writer-Director Sean Durkin
establishes most of the drama through suggestion, slowly building a sense of
dread and foreboding horror, both about Martha’s time in the commune and her
new found home. One near unwatchable scene shows Martha finding solace while
her sister and husband have sex, discovering her curled up next to them as if
it were normal. Most of the flashbacks to life with the cult come from waking
dreams, and it is this dreamlike quality that pervades throughout the film.
Cult leader Patrick (the excellent John Hawkes from Winters Bone) is a
dangerous mix of charm and anger, a volatile man whose attention wanes once he
has deflowered the new arrivals, a wolf in sheep’s clothing with an ode to
Manson. Every female member of the commune must answer the phone as Marlene,
and his nickname for Martha gives the film its title, who we eventually see
taking on the coveted role of training the new girls, who are drugged and raped
in a ritual like act. Durkin’s script evolves into an examination of why we get
lost in our own individualism, with Martha escaping one set of rules for
another, and remaining just as vulnerable as she seemingly has been all her
life.
Paul Berrington
